Showing posts with label Special Situations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Special Situations. Show all posts

Monday, October 14, 2013

Open Offers

Hi,

As discussed last year in the ppt on delisting, given the dwindling opportunities in Delisting space and the worsening risk-reward ratio we have been in search of other special situation opportunities.

The ppt below is an attempt to discuss another special situation opportunity "Open Offers" in detail.

We would like to emphasise that certain portfolio allocation to such special situations gives you absolute returns in a bear market as well. Also one can also shift such positions at minimal loss into long term opportunities if meanwhile market corrections present a more lucrative long term bet.

The following ppt on open offer was made this year at the ISG forum meet in Delhi, CFA Delhi Chapter meet in Delhi and then the IIF forum meet in Mumbai. We have tried to further revise the ppt as per the feedback received.

Look forward to your valuable comments and suggestions :)




Open Offers from perfectresearch


Acknowledgement
The author (Mr. Ashish Kila) would like to thank his entire team, for their extensive help in preparation of the above note.
Disclaimer
  • Nothing in this article is, or should be construed as, investment advice.
  • This is not an offer (or solicitation of an offer) to buy/sell the securities/instruments mentioned.
  • All the posts on this blog, including this one, are for educational and discussion purposes only.
  • Please do not take buy/sell or any investment decision based on articles you read on the blog. These are only meant to provide information and initiate discussion. Final decision is and always should be, yours and only yours.
  • We may or may not have a position in the stocks discussed on this blog. 

Monday, December 10, 2012

Delisting - An Unfair binary game !!!

Hi

It has almost been a year since we last presented on the delisting theme. We have over the period further refined our thought process. Though we have made decent money with the theme, we have realised that risk reward payoffs in delisting are skewed and asymmetrical!!!

Heads you win some, tails you lose a lot !!!

We have humbly tried to share our findings in the following ppt made at an investor forum in 1st week of November 2012, look forward to your comments and suggestions.... plz see ppt at end of post

We would also like to update on certain developments which have materialised post the presentation:
  1. APW - They have still not announced the RBB (Reverse Book Building) process, having invested close to the indicative price level of 195, we have booked our profit and exited from the above considering the above uncertainty
  2. Ricoh - As we feared, the RBB failed because of book not getting complete
  3. Transgene - Shareholders block transgene move to delist ( Link  )
  4. IndoTech - Postal Ballot has passed however given the low level of participation and extremely high level of dissenting shareholders coupled with scattered shareholding has increased the deal risk considerably
  5. DISA - Announced Offer for Sale :( 
  6. Timken - We have exited from our position recommended last year at a profit, the continued investment/focus in unlisted entity doesn't seem positive.

Presentation





Acknowledgement
The author (Mr. Ashish Kila) would like to thank his entire team, for their extensive help in preparation of the above note.

Disclaimer
  • Nothing in this article is, or should be construed as, investment advice.
  • This is not an offer (or solicitation of an offer) to buy/sell the securities/instruments mentioned.
  • All the posts on this blog, including this one, are for educational and discussion purposes only.
  • Please do not take buy/sell or any investment decision based on articles you read on the blog. These are only meant to provide information and initiate discussion. Final decision is and always should be, yours and only yours.
  • We may or may not have a position in the stocks discussed on this blog. 

Sunday, July 08, 2012

Is the Dividend Really Special???

Hi

Have used the case of Numeric Power Systems as an example to analyse a particular special situation - "Slump Sale Cases with Special Dividend in Sight"

1) Event 
The company has sold off its major business to Legrand for a consideration of Rs 837 crs.
The company has announced a board meeting to consider interim dividend on 9th July 2012.

2) Risk Reward Framework Process
Now in such cases, have tried to use a risk reward framework which could be useful in highlighting
a) the odds one has of making some money.
b) whether you want to bet money and 
c) how much capital you would like to allocate to such an opportunity ....

2.1) Probability of a Payout could depend upon the following factors :-

1. Governance Standards of Promoter - No discernible acts of misgovernance 


2. Past Dividend Payouts - Not very high in this case - 8% payout ratio in last few years


3. Promoters interest to come back to markets - Does the promoter want to raise future capital in the 
    market and hence keep a good image in markets      
    - Difficult to judge in this case as Rs 650 cr is a good warchest.  


4. What does he plan to do with the money - in this case the promoter wishes to expand in the solar 
     UPS area - Question is how much money do u think the promoter will invest?


5. How many shares does the promoter group have - Higher the holding, Higher the chances of a 
    reasonable payout - as the majority of money comes back in the hand of promoters - 65.12% in this 
    case


6. Cues from corporate action - Promoters buying etc. could be useful cues - Here holding increased 
    from 63.39 to 65.12% via off market transfer 


7. Promoter Communication - In this case promoters had mentioned their intention in the postal ballot 
    however there was a delay in announcement of the board meeting post completion of deal on 31st 
    May 2012. 
    Also, current omission of the word "Special" in the dividend announcement may be a mere clerical   
    omission or the above activities may be the deliberate attempt of the promoters to moderate dividend 
    expectations 
    Regarding Media Interviews - promoters have not been very media friendly from the start 
    In this video, the body language in the interview again implied a focus on solar as core and   
    some special dividend to be paid...


2.2) Calculation of discount to be applied for valuation of residual cash
Seeing some past cases of Slump Sales 
a) where dividend was paid - JB Chemicals, Smart Link etc. - ~60%
b) where dividend was not paid - Kanoria Chemicals etc. - ~70% 

3) Calculations 
















4) Conclusion
In such cases, with an immediate downside risk, it all boils down to estimation of probabilities and then deciding on the basis of the corresponding expected return.

Though one who doesn't wish to take the event risk, could have also deployed the strategy of buying earlier and selling out on the dividend board meeting  announcement rally (would explain it in another detailed post sometime later)...


Disclaimer
  • Nothing in this article is, or should be construed as, investment advice.
  • This is not an offer (or solicitation of an offer) to buy/sell the securities/instruments mentioned.
  • All the posts on this blog, including this one, are for educational and discussion purposes only.
  • Please do not take buy/sell or any investment decision based on articles you read on the blog. These are only meant to provide information and initiate discussion. Final decision is and always should be, yours and only yours.
  • I may or may not have a position in the stocks discussed on this blog. 

Monday, April 02, 2012

Delisting Ideas - how to evaluate them


PFA presentation on the topic “Delisting Ideas and How to evaluate them”.
The ppt was made by Mr. Ashish Kila last year at an investor forum and covered in business standard subsequently
http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/checklist-for-evaluatingdelisting-proposal/454475/

Look forward to your comments and suggestions
We will be updating the presentation in near future with the latest cases ... 


Tuesday, July 05, 2011

JB Chemicals - Special Situation - Cash due to slump sale

JB chemicals

Though little late in the posting of this idea, the stock fell sharply over uncertainity over cash utilisation when the deal got announced to  ~115 Rs.
Have made some notes from the conf call transcript given by management ....
A
Valuation - As per CMP downside appears limited
Particulars

Amt
Cash in books
Rs per share
102.4
40% discount ('coz investing in pharma business)

40%
After cash
Rs per share
61.42854208
Total Business Revenues before deal
Rs crs
800
Remaining business revenues
Rs crs
615
EV (assuming a price/sales multiple of 1)
Rs crs
615
Net Debt
Rs crs
-22
Equity Value
Rs crs
637
No of shares
Crs
8.45
Per share value (assuming a price/sales multiple of 1)
Rs per share
75
Total Value in case of non payment of dividend
Rs per share
137
CMP on date of analysis
Rs per share
120
B
Calculation Of net debt
Debt as on Mar 2010
Rs cr
136
3 yr avg operating cash flow for 2010-11
Rs cr
80
Cash as on mar 2010
Rs cr
78
Net debt
Rs cr
-22
C
Remaining Business revenues as per mgt in concall
ROW
m$
28
Russia Prescription
m$
22
j&J
m$
20

m$
70
Exchange rate
Rs/$
45

Rs cr
315
Domestic
Rs cr
300
Total
Rs cr
615
D
Cash in books
Cash recd
Rs cr
1160
Escrow acccount (payable 15 months later)
15%
174
Balance receivable after 1 month
Rs cr
986
Discounting with 12%

977
Discounting of escrow money with 12%

147
Present Value of total money receivable

1124
Tax Rate

23%
Final in Domestic
Rs cr
865
Per share cash
Rs
102.4
E
Some +ve developments
1
Ashish Dhawan holding ~7% and buying additional 5.6 lakh shares @128 Rs in NSE after deal
Industry
: Pharmaceuticals & Drugs
House
: Private
Trade Price(Rs.)
Value
 (Rs.in Lakhs)

Deal Date
Client Name
Tran
Qty (000's)

25-May-11
ASHISH DHAWAN
BUY
565446
128.02
72388397

2
Sale of Russia business seems like good riddance as it was not returning funds anyways
3
Mar 2010 consolidated P&L sales roughly ~ Rs740 cr ...almost    half of which is stuck as sundry debtors of Rs 340 cr,
out of which    almost half is debtors more than 6 months i.e. Rs 172 cr....

Historically good dividend payout ratio
F
Possible setbacks
1
Management going back on their words like GeeCee Ventures/ Gwalior Chemicals.
Went back on their word of investing in pharma,  went back on giving dividend, announced buyback and
went ahead with NBFC.  Probability of the above event appears to be low
2
The presence of a savvy investor Like Ashish Dhawan need not ensure that minority share holders interest
is taken care of, as was seen in the Indo asian fusegear where Ashish holds 8%
G
Links:
1
2