Showing posts with label valuation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label valuation. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 24, 2016

Why standard valuation matrix is not the best way to value great businesses

Hi

Every year we strive to share our thought process on the challenges being faced by us in value investing. We started our moat investing journey with the ppt "Role of Management in Long term investing" to highlight that when Buffett says that business quality is more important than management he is referring to the competence of the management, however we wanted to highlight that in India a lot of managements are unethical and an investor needs to be discerning enough to differentiate the good from the bad. Else money will be made only by the management and not the minority 

Then we discussed on our 4C's of Investing Process (Cloning, Checklist, Capital Allocation & Checkout) on how we shortlist ideas, bet money and exit them.

Now we discuss that since stocks are no longer trading at attractive multiples, the standard valuation matrix of PE multiples would not help us hold on or buy great businesses. So the post attempts to discuss a framework to value great businesses. 

The topic of the ppt is "why standard valuation matrix is not the best way to value great businesses", the ppt was presented at various forums like IIF and FLAME Investment Lab - Alumni Meet in Pune recently. Foundation for Liberal And Management Education (FLAME)

We also won the best speaker prize at FLAME 2015 alumni meet for the above presentation and we were gifted a great book - "Anatomy of the Bear: Lessons from Wall Street's Four Great Bottoms". One can read about Flame Investment Lab here.

We look forward to your comments and suggestions on how we can further improve this process...



To download the Presentation- Please visit this link  
Acknowledgement
The author (Mr. Ashish Kila) would like to thank his entire team, for their extensive help in preparation of the above note.
Disclaimer
  • We are not SEBI registered Investment Advisor
  • Nothing in this article is, or should be construed as, investment advice. The stocks mentioned in the post are for educational purpose only and are not recommendations, the purpose of this post is to highlight a framework which an investor can apply to any company.
  • This is not an offer (or solicitation of an offer) to buy/sell the securities/instruments mentioned.
  • All the posts on this blog, including this one, are for educational and discussion purposes only.
  • Please do not take buy/sell or any investment decision based on articles you read on the blog. These are only meant to provide information and initiate discussion. Final decision is and always should be, yours and only yours.
  • We may or may not have a position in the stocks discussed on this blog

Sunday, June 01, 2008

Relevance of SOTP in bear markets

In bear markets hardly anyone looks at SOTP. But i guess certain assets can be valued by this method only...

The SOTP valuation is done to include valuation of non core businesses. When the core business is under pressure investors do not look at non core valuations. M&M and Tata Motors are examples of this phenomen...

Saturday, September 01, 2007

DCF/Relative Valuation


Consistencies in DCF
• If we use real cash flows for forecasting (ie don’t build in inflation) we should use a real discount rate and not a nominal rate.
• If there is some source of other income like cash or marketable securities
a) Either build the annual income every year in your cash flow forecasts
b) Or deduct the total source of income after calculating enterprise value …logic being to acquire a company you need to pay EV but you also get the company’s cash which can be used to reduce your acquisition costs. Second method is preferable as it doesn’t involve forecasting such cash flows every year

Assumptions of Valuation methods
o DCF assumes mkt price may deviate from intrinsic value in short term but will get corrected over the long term
o Relative valuation assumes while individual companies might be mispriced the sector or the mkt as a whole is priced properly

Can a Firm be Undervalued and Over valued at the same time
If DCF shows a firm is overvalued however relative valuation suggests it is undervalued – the whole sector in fact might be overvalued and vice-versa. Eg. In March 2000, Amazon’s DCF value was $30, it traded at 70$ (overvalued), however still appeared cheaper on a relative basis compared to other internet companies.

Source-
• Damodaran on Valuation – Second Edition
• Job interviews :)

Saturday, August 18, 2007

Something to ponder – ROE, ROCE

Through leverage the company takes on debt and can raise its ROE above its ROCE as long as ROCE is higher than the net cost of debt.

Wednesday, July 25, 2007

what is cheaper debt or equity


Please point out flaw in the argument below

Was discussing cost of equity vs cost of debt with a friend of mine with regards to BEML as to why it went for raising high cost equity when it can raise low cost debt considering it has negligible debt on its balancesheet

He raised an interesting point…(although the explanation is simplistic and has obvious flaws, I still think we can refresh our concepts)

Which was that practically cost of equity is nothing in today’s mkts
  • you raise money at premiums of > Rs 1000 (price band of Rs.1020 - Rs.1090 per equity share)
  • and what do you pay as a dividend is a measely 10 Rs dividend (optimistic scenario 100% div on Face value of 10 Rs which it has been paying for the past 2 yrs )
  • what about the other component of return ie capital appreciation … there is no outgo involved for firm
  • so cost for firm -> 10/1020 = ~1%
Consider debt:- you raise money@8 -9 %
  • so cost for firm is 8% (1-tax) = 5.6%

    so which is cheaper equity or debt ???
---------------------------------------------
Equity Dividend 38.29 CR
Equity Dividend (%) 100.00
No of shares in issue – 3.68 cr (PRE FPO issue)

Source
http://www.moneycontrol.com/india/stockpricequote/engineering/bharatearthmovers/23/22/profitloss/marketprice/BEM
http://www.moneypore.com/
some replies recieved
view 1

If stock is over valued, equity is cheaperThe older shareholders benefit at the expense of the new onesIf the valuation is under valued, that means that the debt servicing capability of the business is much higher in relation to market accorded valuation, in that scenario debt is cheaper

view 2
Though i agree with the logical sense of the argument below, the key to all of this is which is more beneficial to the exisitng investor - that a company raises low cost debt or high cost equity. Eventually, the burden of the higher cost equity will reflect on RoEs and future growth rates of the company. A typical example of this is Gateway Ditriparks which underwent a huge equity raising exercise 2 years back and has been a laggard in the last 1 year

view 3
This is not wrong but ignores the fundamental fact that optimum dilution should be done at a time when company is close to have its valuations move upwards sharply, more so in case of project based company. Till such time, funding needs be better met by debt.

Friday, August 18, 2006

Bonds Vs Equity

Was having discussion with my friend on how he views bonds Vs equity
my friends take
“I view bonds as an inferior way of allocating my capital. They don't have a lot of upside ( no incremental earnings, due to their very fixed nature ) and a lot of downside ( they are totally dependent on the business in question being able to keep it's promises )

On the other hand, if we invest in high grade equity bought at a bargain price, we stand to atleast eliminate the upside opportunity costs to some extent. The downside depends in both cases, on the extent and rigour of our analysis of the company.

Now, if we compare stocks and bonds of the same company, if our analysis And logic are solid, devoid of any prejudices, we stand to eliminate the distinction between stocks and bonds as such. An equity holding would translate into almost bond status because of the assurance of no erosion in value and a large upside.

As always, my two doubts are dependent on a lot of externalities which I cannot possibly explain in just a single mail.”

To which I replied

Actually sent him a summary of an excellent article I had read earlier

Investors should buy the common shares and sell short the bonds of companies where the equity yield is higher than the inflation-adjusted (real) bond yield, provided the dividend is secure.

Four reasons to pursue this strategy:

(1) dividends will likely rise faster than inflation providing investors with a higher real return,
(2) equity provides greater capital appreciation potential than debt,
(3) Treasury yields are expected to rise in 2005, (Yr 2005 specific)
(4) corporate spreads are unlikely to narrow from current levels, (Yr 2005 specific)

Logic

Dividend yield higher than real debt yield does not make economic sense. An asset with higher growth potential theoretically should offer less current yield than a similar asset with lower growth potential.
The average difference between investment grade corporate debt real yield and the S&P 500 dividend yield has been 480 basis points since 1994. If the dividend yield is higher than the real bond yield for a particular company, investors would seem to be expecting a dividend cut.

However, if the dividend is secure, the yield differential should adjust over time through the shares appreciating (dividend yield falls) or bond price erosion (yield rises). This adjustment can come from one or both sides.